Apply cash with disputed invoices

Reviewed by Ijaz Ali, ACCA · Updated November 2026

You are the staff accountant at Lakeview Industrial Supply Ltd. The controller asks you to apply a verified $4,650 customer EFT. Use the remittance and leave the pricing dispute open. The invoice balances include any tax already billed. There are no authorised credits or write-offs.

Customer ledger before cash application
InvoiceOriginalPrior paymentDue status
B-208$3,400$40012 days overdue
B-211$2,200—38 days overdue
B-219$900—Current
Remittance
ReferenceAmountNote
B-208$3,000Pay remaining balance
B-211$1,500Pricing dispute on balance
Unspecified$150No invoice reference

Your tasks

  1. Calculate the open balance of each invoice before and after the EFT.
  2. Reconcile the EFT to confirmed allocations and the unapplied remainder.
  3. Prepare the receipt posting and recommend how to handle the dispute and unapplied cash.

Check your figures

  1. Remaining open on B-211
  2. Unapplied receipt
  3. Gross open invoices after matching

Make the decision

How should the pricing dispute be handled?

Reveal worked solution

Opening gross open invoices were $3,000 on B-208, $2,200 on B-211 and $900 on B-219, totalling $6,100. Apply $3,000 to B-208 and $1,500 to B-211, leaving $0, $700 and $900 respectively, or $1,600 gross open. The $4,650 EFT equals $4,500 applied plus $150 unapplied. Keep the $700 dispute open without changing its aging bucket.

Receipt and cash application (CAD)
EntryAccountDebitCredit
Record verified EFTCash$4,650—
Accounts receivable — B-208—$3,000
Accounts receivable — B-211—$1,500
Unapplied cash liability—$150

Document your recommendation

Write a short note to the controller that explains the reconciliation, entries and evidence to retain.

Compare with a model controller note

I applied $4,500 of the $4,650 EFT to the two invoices identified on the remittance. Open invoices total $1,600, including the $700 pricing dispute. I recommend holding $150 as unapplied cash, asking the customer for allocation instructions and routing the dispute to the pricing team.

In the workplace

  1. Ask the customer for the invoice reference for the $150 and request evidence for the $700 pricing dispute.
  2. In SAP, clear customer open items by invoice and reconcile unapplied receipts separately. Require approval for credit notes or write-offs.

What’s next

Try another case:

Review the related lesson: Payment matching

Want one-to-one help with month-end close or SAP? Book a free 30-minute intro

All companies, people and figures in this case are fictional and for study purposes only.

About the tutor

Ijaz Ali is an ACCA-qualified Senior Accountant with over 10 years of experience in financial reporting, month-end close and SAP FICO. He is a former SAP FICO instructor and runs The Accounting Nest YouTube channel.

Watch on YouTube